INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS
Log In
Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving . By joining you are opting in to receive .
Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.
Eng-Tips Posting Policies
Water line fittings
thread164- Forum Search FAQs Links MVPsForum
Search
FAQs
Links
MVPs
(Civil/Environmental)
(OP)
1 Dec 12 16:44Simple question: Are wye fittings ever used on water mains? I'm used to seeing tees where a water line connects with another one, but I have a set of drawings in front of me on which the engineer is showing a lot of, what I consider unnecessary, wyes. The water mains are primarily 8" and 12".
Replies continue below
(Civil/Environmental)
2 Dec 12 10:38Doesn't make much sense unless they are there to just use up some extra stuff laying around.
Richard A. Cornelius, P.E.
WWW.amlinereast.com
(Civil/Environmental)
The company is the world’s best y fitting supplier. We are your one-stop shop for all needs. Our staff are highly-specialized and will help you find the product you need.
2 Dec 12 10:42unless it is a gravity line, no need foor wyes
(Civil/Environmental)
2 Dec 12 13:24Agree with the previous comments
(Civil/Environmental)
3 Dec 12 13:43Wyes are certainly available and can be used, but I've never seen one in a water distrubution system. A tee + 45° ELL is standard.The only time I've see a wye on a water line was on a wall-mounted 8" pipe in a wastewater treatement plant. The wye was used there because of space constraints.
==========
"Is it the only lesson of history that mankind is unteachable?"
--Winston S. Churchill
(Civil/Environmental)
4 Dec 12 22:29Over the years I guess I've seen wyes occasionally specified in water systems. However, wyes have traditionally been "special" items (not shown/detailed in standards like more common tees and bends etc.), and therefore they are of basically/mostly proprietary designs. Due to the very sharp/acute turn where the branch meets the body, they are also a fitting that concentrates stress more than others, and at least in larger sizes must be reinforced to dependably handle high pressures. All of these factors also play into generally less availability and higher costs of/for wye fittings.
(Geotechnical)
5 Dec 12 18:15I've never seen or designed a wye on a potable water system, but I have less than ten years experience in potable water and only in the Southeast U.S.
(Civil/Environmental)
19 Dec 12 17:54I have seen a few times on drawings from other engineers. In those few instances I have made it a point to have them removed. As many have said here, they do not make sense. In terms of hydraulics, and depending on overall system configuration, the minor losses through that fitting would be greater than a 90 degree elbow as water would attempt to turn the corner. Even more for larger size pipes as original posts states.
(Civil/Environmental)
5 Jan 13 01:27Most of the time the master plan f towns is not suitable to use wyes but, if it is why not? They are better in hydraulics than tee and 45deg. elbow that's why they are used at suction or delivery pipes of pump
(Civil/Environmental)
7 Jan 13 09:43Alula, most water distribution systems are looped and the flow of the water can go in any direction. Imagine if you have a wye in a line that is going up and the wye is going to the right, you will have less headloss than you would for a standard tee if the water is flowing that direction. But, if the water is flowing down and trying to go left into the wye, you will have much greater headloss than a tee. Because you don't know which direction the water will be flowing at any given time, overall you would have less headloss with a tee than you do a wye.
Hope this makes sense.
(Civil/Environmental)
7 Jan 13 15:33We would avoid wyes because we want to have off-the-shelf components in case we need to replace them in an emergency. Our local distributor will have tees and 45s in stock, but won't have wyes. Replacing a wye with a tee and 45 isn't as simple once the connecting pipe is buried.
(Mechanical)
11 Jan 13 14:06Agree. They are used in HVAC and plumbing ALL the time. Plumbing somewhat invalidated the "off the shelf" issue noted above (you may have an issue with certain materials being off the shelf, but they do exist). For pumping systems, not used so much. I have seen it, but the plant later reversed the flow in the lines due to re-configurationQuote (cvg)
unless it is a gravity line, no need for wyes
.Quote (coloeng)
But, if the water is flowing down and trying to go left into the wye,
Agree. They are used in HVAC and plumbing ALL the time. Plumbing somewhat invalidated the "off the shelf" issue noted above (you may have an issue with certain materials being off the shelf, but they do exist). For pumping systems, not used so much. I have seen it, but the plant later reversed the flow in the lines due to re-configuration
Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.
Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.
Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members! Already a Member? Login
If you want to learn more, please visit our website gi pipe price list philippines.