3D printing with PLA vs. ABS: What's the difference?

09 Sep.,2024

 

3D printing with PLA vs. ABS: What's the difference?

PLA and ABS are the two most common materials for prototyping (desktop) FDM 3D printing (aside from, perhaps, PETG). As thermoplastics, both filaments enter a soft and moldable state when heated, returning to a solid-state when cooled. FDM printers melt and extrude PLA and ABS filament through a nozzle to build up parts layer by layer.

HYF are exported all over the world and different industries with quality first. Our belief is to provide our customers with more and better high value-added products. Let's create a better future together.

While both materials are used for FDM, they have key differences that make each more optimal for different applications. In this article, we&#;ll cover the main differences between these commonly used materials.

We also have this handy Youtube explainer video that covers the differences between PLA and ABS filaments.


Want to compare pricing for PLA and ABS?

Upload your CAD file to the Quote Builder

What is PLA? Printing with polylactic acid

PLA (Polylactic Acid) is a thermoplastic derived from renewable sources such as cornstarch or sugarcane. Biodegradable under the right conditions, PLA is one of the most popular bioplastics and is perfect for a variety of applications ranging from plastic cups to medical implants.

Compared to many other 3D printing materials, PLA is quite cost-efficient, providing good value for money in exchange for high-quality components with relatively smooth surface finishes. PLA is easy to print with and has a higher stiffness than ABS and other materials like nylon, though it doesn't handle high temperatures or significant stress so well. While PLA is stronger than ABS and nylon, it&#;s not very heat or chemical-resistant. 

What is ABS? Printing with Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene

ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene) is another common thermoplastic. It's a common fixture in 3D printing and quite popular in the world of injection molding. Real-world applications of ABS include toys (think LEGO bricks), housings for electronics, automotive parts, household appliances and much more.

Tough and resistant to impact to a certain point, ABS has superior mechanical properties to PLA while being lighter and more durable. However, the tradeoff is that it's harder to print with and often requires higher temperatures for effective printing. The material can deflect heat more effectively than PLA, but it's absolutely not known for total heat resistance. And for 3D printer operators, be aware that ABS can produce strong odors during the manufacturing process.

What&#;s the difference between PLA and ABS? 

PLA and ABS differ in several ways, including their unique tensile strength, density and ideal applications. The table below compares the key material properties of PLA and ABS filaments.

Properties* ABS PLA Tensile Strength** 27 MPa 37 MPa Elongation 3.5 - 50% 6% Flexural Modulus 2.1 - 7.6 GPa 4 GPa Density 1.0 - 1.4 g/cm3 1.3 g/cm3 Melting Point 200 &#; 173 &#; Biodegradable No Yes, under the correct conditions Glass Transition Temperature 105 &#; 60 &#; Spool Price*** (1kg, 1.75mm, black) $USD 21.99 $USD 22.99 Common Products LEGO, electronic housings Cups, plastic bags, cutlery

What is the part accuracy of PLA and ABS?

In general, the tolerances and accuracy of FDM printed components depend on printer calibration and model complexity. However, you can use PLA and ABS to create dimensionally accurate parts with printing details of 0.8 mm and minimum features of 1.2 mm. For connecting or interlocking parts, we recommend a tolerance of 0.5 mm and a minimum wall thickness of 1-2 mm. This will ensure that your part has adequate strength across all wall elements. 

Thanks to its lower printing temperature, PLA is easier to print with and less likely to warp (when properly cooled). You can use PLA to print sharper corners and finer features than with ABS.


Want to improve your 3D printing design skills?

Download our free 3D printing design rules poster

How strong are PLA and ABS parts?

PLA and ABS have similar tensile strengths, making them solid options for many prototyping applications. Designers and engineers often prefer ABS due to its improved ductility over PLA. ABS has higher flexural strength and better elongation before breaking than PLA, which means that ABS can also be used for end-use applications. PLA, on the other hand, is more popular for rapid prototyping when the form is more critical than the function.

Overall, PLA is a good option for your custom parts if you don&#;t plan on putting them under a lot of physical stress (or UV radiation and high temperatures). ABS is more fitting for industrial applications and can weather physical strain better than PLA.

How fast can you print with PLA and ABS?

Both PLA and ABS print at nearly identical speeds. This means that you don&#;t have to change speed settings on your FDM machines when switching between materials. For PLA, printing at 60 mm/s is pretty standard, though some operators have printed at over 150 mm/s, so the standard speed is by no means a limit. You can also print ABS at the same speed, but between 40-60 mm/s is a bit more accurate for this material.


Surface finishes and post-processing for PLA and ABS

Whether you produce parts using PLA or ABS, FDM-printed components will always have visible layers. Using PLA often results in a glossier finish, while ABS typically prints in a matte finish. To smooth an ABS-printed part and give it a glossy finish, you can use acetone in post-processing. Sanding and additional machining are viable post-processing options for parts printed in ABS. You can also sand and machine PLA, though greater care is required. 

If aesthetic quality is critical, then we recommend using SLA 3D printing to produce your custom parts. 


Want to explore all the options for FDM post-processing?

Learn more

How heat resistant are PLA and ABS?

For applications requiring higher temperatures, ABS (glass transition temperature of 105°C) is preferable over PLA (glass transition temperature of 60°C). PLA can rapidly lose its structural integrity and can begin to droop and deform as it approaches 60°C, especially if it's supporting a heavier load. 

Are PLA and ABS biodegradable?

PLA is stable in general atmospheric conditions, though it will biodegrade within 50 days in industrial composters and 48 months in water. While ABS is not biodegradable, you can recycle it. This being the case, manufacturers tend to use PLA to produce items related to food service, though we absolutely recommend you get safety confirmation from filament manufacturers. 




If you want to learn more, please visit our website uses of pla.

Frequently asked questions

When should you use PLA?

PLA is ideal when you&#;re looking for higher-quality aesthetics. Its lower printing temperature makes it easier to print with than ABS, especially if your parts have fine details.

When should you use ABS?

ABS is best suited for applications where you need strength, ductility, machinability and thermal stability. Being more durable than PLA makes ABS a viable option for prototyping, low-stress end-use components and other practical applications. However, be aware that ABS is more prone to warping.

How strong are PLA and ABS?

PLA and ABS are similar in terms of their tensile strengths, though engineers often go for ABS as it has better ductility than PLA. ABS has higher flexural strength and better elongation before breaking than PLA.


Are PLA and ABS flexible?

Unlike TPU, PLA and ABS aren&#;t flexible filament materials, though ABS is less brittle than PLA in nearly all applications.

Is PLA or ABS more expensive?

PLA and ABS tend to have similar prices, which can reach approximately $40 to $75 (&#;36 to &#;68) per kg filament spool. ABS is likely cheaper than PLA if you&#;re considering only the cost of the raw materials. Also, PLA&#;s wider variety of brands, colors, and blends make it more popular than ABS. 


How long do PLA and ABS last?

Parts made from PLA and ABS will last a long time (decades, in fact), so long as they&#;re not used in a heavy load-bearing capacity.


Are PLA and ABS toxic?

When you heat any thermoplastic, it releases fumes, some of which may contain harmful particulates. PLA is plant-based, so it shouldn&#;t give off any bad odors or noxious fumes. However, ABS tends to be more toxic than PLA and can smell much worse. That&#;s why we recommend using a proper enclosure and ventilation system.


Is the specialty support filament worth it?

I have been using the Bambu support material and I think it works well, but I haven&#;t tried using PETG yet.

When you select the Bambu support for the support material interface a box shows up recommending to set:

0 top z
0 interface spacing
Concentric pattern
Disable independent support later height

If you click yes on the box, it will set it for you.

Most of the time it is easy to get off, but sometimes it is hard, especially when it&#;s supporting a flat surface. Make sure to wait until the model is completely cool, otherwise it is harder to take off.

IMPORTANT: Set the flush to 700 when going from the support material to any of the PLA spools, otherwise it will mix with the PLA and potentially cause layer separation at the layer printed after switching to PLA. A number lower than 700 might work, but that is the number I am using for now.

I use the following tools to help

Strong thin point tweezers

I hardly use the tweezers anymore after getting these two pliers. I hesitated because of the price, but it is definitely worth it. Both in quality and especially usefulness.

https://www.amazon.ca/gp/aw/d/B000IBSFPS?psc=1&ref=ppx_pop_mob_b_asin_title

https://www.amazon.ca/gp/aw/d/B000IBSFPS?psc=1&ref=ppx_pop_mob_b_asin_title

I use most of the tools in this set when removing supports. They make things easier.

https://www.amazon.ca/gp/aw/d/B072HTBDK7?psc=1&ref=ppx_pop_mob_b_asin_title

A good precision blade set, like X-acto knives. I have a cheap set that came with a 3D printer combination set that I will replace so some point, so I won&#;t advertise it, buy something better. But it has served me well so far. I especially like this blade.

It is good for when the support material is stuck to a flat surface. I stick the pointed end between the support interface and PLA and push, which separates it at that spot. Just use the blade to start it, you don&#;t have to use it on the whole surface, you then use your fingers or tweezers or pliers to pull it, it comes off easily after that.

Contact us to discuss your requirements of High Shrinkage Ratio PVC Film. Our experienced sales team can help you identify the options that best suit your needs.