How to save costs when making a custom enclosure

02 Dec.,2024

 

How to save costs when making a custom enclosure

You have developed an electronic gadget and decided that you can take that product to the next level with a few improvements and insights in the target market. So, pumped up, you modify your electronics and add features that might require a custom or customised housing instead of that diecast box you bought online.

You can find more information on our web, so please take a look.

You decide to contact an industrial designer to help you develop a professional-looking custom enclosure. They proceed to tell you it will cost upwards of tens of thousands of dollars ($50K&#;$120K) to design and tool for what you thought was a relatively simple custom enclosure. Deflated, you balk at the cost and wonder if this is really a viable project.

This is a common scenario in electronic design. Making a custom enclosure can be complicated and frustrating when you consider the amount of options that are now available. From years of experience in this space, here are some considerations that we believe can help minimise time/cost and maximise value in the process of making a custom enclosure:

  • Think about your enclosure design first.
  • Can I customise instead of custom design?
  • To tool not to tool: that is the question.

Think about your enclosure design first

This sounds obvious, right? Tooling is expensive, so it is important to get your design right. Design is expensive and charged by the hour; therefore, it is also important to specify your requirements clearly to reduce the amount of information loops and adjustments (ie, hours) required. It&#;s an easy thing to say, but in practice it can be hard to know where to start when you have not even fleshed out your system design. Here are some tips on what to consider when embarking on enclosure design that might help you avoid pitfalls later in the process.

First, consider your realistic quantity for the lifetime of product. What will be the continuity plan for this design? Are you developing to grow to an ultimate quantity over time, or will you this be a staged process with redesign each production run?

Next, write down functional specification and relate it to desired enclosure features. Typical things to consider are:

  • PCB dimension
  • Material
  • IP rating
  • Connectors
  • Sensors
  • Buttons
  • External indicators/displays
  • Type of mounting
  • What are the other unique functions special to your design?
     

For example, see the below functions for an IoT sensor enclosure:

Function Feature Comments Handheld and wall mountable Small, clip mount Target space profile
WxHxD =
50 x 20 x 45 Must be accessible for service, battery change Removable lid or door   Ingress protection IP65 Or higher Sun-proof UV stabilised   Non-flammable plastic UL94   Enclosed wireless transmitting Must be plastic   External button IP65 button gland Reset button Drop-proof Thick enough plastic or bumper shock proof  

Now decide how important cosmetic appearance is. Appearance is usually high on the list of reasons why to develop a custom enclosure in the first place. However, there are only so many ways to implement some features.

Now you have laid bare what is critical you can start analysing what is viable.

Customise instead of design custom

  • If you consider that your ongoing quantity point is not in the hundred thousands, it may be more sensible to look at standard options that can be modified to suit, eg, under pieces it might be best to go with a rapid prototyping technology:
    • Additive manufacture
    • Custom metal enclosure
    • Modify a standard enclosure
  • Consult with enclosure manufacturers to get advice on what&#;s possible and what&#;s not.
  • Avoid I/O and connections on too many edges.
  • Metal or plastics?
  • Where possible, use standard options and materials.

To tool or not to tool: that is the question

Injection moulds are expensive but result in low cost in volume. Personally, I would look at low-volume injection moulding using cheaper aluminium tooling. The tooling wears much more quickly but can get you started faster/cheaper. You would design the part (sketches &#; 3D CAD), 3D print to verify function, pass the design to the injection moulding company (design verification and pricing), pay for the tooling, run first article(s), verify function/aesthetics, make changes/verify again, and go into production. The process is expensive and time-consuming no matter what.

At cases, go with rapid prototype tooling.

The key to tooling with these vendors is to be a very good designer of injection moulded components. If you don&#;t follow the design guidelines dead on, your parts will suffer cosmetically.

ERNTEC has been designing and manufacturing enclosure solutions for many years. Talk to us for standard, modified or fully custom solutions.

10 Tips to Save Money on PCB Manufacturing - Fusion Blog

Don&#;t break the bank &#; save money with these ten practical PCB manufacturing tips.

Getting that PCB of yours manufactured is no easy feat, and there&#;s a boat load of machinery, human labor, and processes that make it all happen. But your list of concerns is probably different and involves getting your board back promptly while saving some money. That&#;s why we&#;re here &#; to help you avoid any unnecessary complexity and errors in your PCB design that can take a huge amount out of your wallet come manufacturing time. So without further ado, here are ten practical PCB manufacturing tips that are guaranteed to save you money on your next trip to the fab house.

Two Quick Disclaimers

First, this guide is for members of our community who are just venturing out into PCB design and manufacturing. We won&#;t cover anything super complex related to high-speed design impedances, blind/buried vias, etc. Second, any of the values we listed in this blog post should be verified with your manufacturer, since every fab house uses their own machinery and processes. Measure twice, cut once!

1. Keep Your Board Size at a Minimum

While this one might be the most obvious, it&#;s also the one factor that can take a huge chunk out of your wallet. Always try to keep your completed board size to a minimum, as the bigger it gets, the bigger your costs get. This also works the other way around. If you make your board too small, a manufacturer will need very precise equipment to put everything together, also costing more. So at the end of the day it&#;s a balancing act for you to navigate between size and complexity, but try to err on the side of less is more.

ACE contains other products and information you need, so please check it out.

Yeah that might be a bit overkill &#; keep your PCBs at a minimum size for easy manufacturing, within reason!

2. Don&#;t Skimp on Quality Materials

Before you go and tell your manufacturer to use one of those cheaper, substitute materials for your layer stack, hear us out. Think about when you get that board back. What if it fails within days, weeks, or months after you power it up?

If you skimp on materials now, you&#;ll probably wind up losing more money in the long run when you find that your boards are glorified coffee coasters. So when it comes to selecting materials for your layer stack, use the standard, quality stuff &#; it&#;s there for a reason.

Copper Clad PCB Material Guide

3. Stick with Standard Board Shapes

Unless you have a crazy looking enclosure to fit your design in, always design your board in the standard square and rectangular shapes characteristic of most PCBs. Doing anything out of the norm will skyrocket your manufacturing costs significantly. Also, don&#;t&#; bother adding any internal cutouts to your PCB unless you need it to mount to an enclosure. Keep it simple!

Keep it simple with standard, rectangular PCB shapes to save money on manufacturing.

4. Stay Within Your Minimum Spacing Requirements

This one works just the opposite of your board size. As the spacing between your copper objects like pads and tracks decreases, the more your manufacturing costs will increase. The reasoning behind this is fairly simple. The more stuff you pack into a smaller package, the more precise the manufacturing machinery will need to be. Many fab houses have a standard set of spacing requirements, which is somewhere around 8-10 mils minimum spacing between pads, tracks and track widths.

All of the spaces you&#;ll need to be aware of from your manufacturer, between pads, between tracks, and the width of tracks. (Image source)

Always check with your manufacturer to see their specific spacing requirements. And save yourself from some added worry about adding design rules in your PCB design software for these spacing requirements so you don&#;t need to think about it while you design.

5. Use the Biggest Diameter Possible for Holes

The smaller your holes and annular rings, the higher your manufacturing costs will climb. Again, it comes down to smaller spacing needing precise machinery. Many fab houses will even charge extra if you need holes that are smaller than 0.4mm, so be sure to give your manufacturer a call to avoid any unnecessary costs.

A regular annular ring on a PCB that meets the 0.4mm diameter requirement for manufacturing.

6. Use the Right Via for the Job

There are three types of vias: through-hole vias, blind vias, and buried vias. You&#;ll only use the last two for high density and high-frequency PCBs. So this one is simple: if your design doesn&#;t need these types of vias, leave them out to avoid any extra manufacturing costs.

A good example of all three via types used on a board. For simple designs, stick with the through-hole via for easy manufacturing.

7. Chill Out on the Extra Layers

Before you go adding a bunch of additional layers for more routing space, power planes, or performance, think again. The difference between a four layer board and a two layer board is double! Keep things clean and compact on your next design, and only use as many layers as needed to get the job done, even if that means a little more in board size.

8. Set Your Design Up for Panelization

At a fab house, PCBs are made on a giant panel with a bunch of other PCBs, or just yours depending on how many you ordered. You can save yourself a ton of money at this point by using the largest panel size available from your manufacturer. Getting all of your boards on one panel means that rapid-fire pick and place machine can get all your parts placed in one go without requiring any additional setup time.

9. Use Only Industry Standard Sizes and Components

There&#;s a reason why the electronics industry uses a standardized set of sizes and components &#; it makes everyone&#;s job easier and more efficient. It also adds some potential for automation in all of those high-tech pieces of manufacturing equipment. To avoid any wasted money required from having your manufacturer assemble your weird components by hand, stick with the industry standard specifications, which may differ between each fab house.

10. Stick with Surface Mount Components If Possible

Last but not least, unless you&#;re building a mega complex design, it&#;s best to stick with standard surface mount components (also called Surface Mount Devices, or SMDs). Why? A few reasons:

  • Using surface mount components will reduce the amount of holes that need to be drilled on your board that are typically used for through-hole components.

  • This will also reduce the number of processes required to get all of your parts soldered onto your board.

  • You will likely get your board back in less time, as through-hole components require hand assembly by a certified person.

Use surface mount components for quick and easy manufacturing with no hand assembly required.

If you decide to go with a mixed-component technology with both surface mount and through-hole parts, prepare for some added costs. These type of setup will require multiple passes through the soldering oven and some manual hand assembly.

Enjoy Your Saved Money!

So there you have it, ten practical PCB manufacturing tips that will save you loads of money on your next PCB design. A reminder: do your homework by checking with your manufacturer to see what their specific requirements are for spacing, hole diameters, panelization, etc. And you never know, your fab house might have some cost-saving tips of their own to offer.

Ready to get started? Try out these PCB manufacturing tips in Autodesk Fusion 360 today!

Contact us to discuss your requirements of semiconductor enclosures. Our experienced sales team can help you identify the options that best suit your needs.